Fact Check

Did Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Say 'Under Capitalism, Man Oppresses Man. Under Socialism, It's Just the Opposite'?

It seems a little unlikely that a 29-year-old would be the originator of an "old Soviet joke" several decades old.

Published Dec 13, 2018

 (AP Photo/Susan Walsh)
Image Via AP Photo/Susan Walsh
Claim:
Newly elected Democratic Party Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said, "'Under capitalism, man oppresses man. Under socialism, it's just the opposite.'"

The political opposition's fixation with incoming Democratic Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York continued in December 2018 with the online sharing of a graphic that attempted to link her to a quote whose origins have been disputed.

The graphic, first posted a month earlier, showed a black-and-white picture of the congresswoman-elect alongside the phrase "Under capitalism, man oppresses man. Under socialism, it's just the opposite."

The meme was subsequently spread by a Facebook page listed for musician Ted Nugent, with the addition of the caption "Do not shut this woman up. This shit is gold":

We consulted Ocasio-Cortez seeking comment but have yet to hear back. However, not only did we find no record of her having made such a statement, the phrase itself is a misstated version of a much older phrase with unclear origins.

The original version -- "Under capitalism man exploits man. Under socialism it's just the opposite." -- has long been attributed to economist John Kenneth Galbraith, who passed away in 2006. But it has also been described in other accounts as an "old Soviet joke" or a "wry Russian joke," including in Jules Archer's 1977 book Police State: Could It Happen Here? -- published 12 years before Ocasio-Cortez was born:

As we have previously chronicled, Ocasio-Cortez has been particularly targeted by mockery and false claims about her.

Sources

Crook, Clive.   "John Kenneth Galbraith, Revisited."     The Atlantic.   May 2006.

Archer, Jules.   Police State: Could It Happen Here?     Harper & Row, 1977.   ISBN 0060201533.

O'Brien, Anthony Patrick.   "Your View: The Pitfalls of Socialism in America."     The Morning Call.   13 December 2018.

Arturo Garcia is a former writer for Snopes.

Become
a Member

Your membership is the foundation of our sustainability and resilience.

Perks

Ad-Free Browsing on Snopes.com
Members-Only Newsletter
Cancel Anytime
default