Fact Check

The Follower

Rumor: Photograph shows a kayaker being trailed by a Great White shark.

Published Mar 30, 2006


Claim:   Photograph shows a kayaker being trailed by a Great White shark.


Example:   [Collected via e-mail, 2006]

Hello I received this photo today, supposedly taken off Capetown, can you verify it please??

Click photo to enlarge


Origins:   Scarcely a week goes by in which we don't receive yet another photograph of a shark for verification,
such is our fascination with these mysterious predators of the deep. Of especial interest are pictures that show humans in (apparently) imminent danger from threatening

sharks, such as the infamous images of a diver attempting to board a helicopter just ahead of some breaching jaws (fake) and a surfer headed directly towards lurking trouble (misidentified).

The image above displays, according to its caption, a kayaker "sitting in a 3.8-metre sea kayak and watching a four-metre great white approach." This photograph is genuine and was taken from a September 2005 Africa Geographic article titled "Shark Detectives," about researchers studying Great White sharks off the coast of South Africa, that described the circumstances under which this picture was snapped:

Sitting in a 3.8-metre sea kayak and watching a four-metre great white approach you is a fairly tense experience. Although we had extensively tested the sharks' reactions to an empty kayak and had observed no signs of aggression, this gave us little comfort as we eyed a great white heading straight for us, albeit slowly. Just a metre or so from the craft it veered off, circled and slowly approached from behind. It did this several times, occasionally lifting its head out of the water to get a better look. Then it lost interest, and as it continued on its way we were able to follow a short distance behind. Once we'd come to terms with having nothing between ourselves and a four-metre shark except a thin layer of plastic, our kayak made an ideal research platform for observing great white behaviour in shallow water. Its advantages are twofold: it is inconspicuous and appears not to cause the sharks to alter their behaviour for long, and it allows us to watch them in a natural situation, as it is not necessary to attract them to us with food.

A similar article appearing in the December 2005 issue of the South African publication The Big Issue included another photograph from the same sequence.

Last updated:   29 May 2015


    Bos, Thessa and Andy Brandy Casagrande IV.   "Sharky Shores."

    The Big Issue.   December 2005.

    Peschak, Thomas P. and Michael C. Scholl.   "Shark Detectives."

    Africa Geographic.   September 2005.

David Mikkelson founded the site now known as snopes.com back in 1994.

Article Tags