Some of President Trump’s ardent online fans have been circulating a collage of snapshots that shows politicians sleeping at their desks, accusing U.S. Congress of being lazy with the sarcastic remark “Our Congress hard at work.”
The image was circulated by Twitter accounts such as “Agent Renee” (whose profile featured 4 American flags and a reference to President Trump’s “Make America Great Again” slogan), LinkedIn pages for people such as “Veronica MAGA Montague” (which also displayed an unusual amount of flags and uses the president’s slogan as a middle name), and Facebook profiles ostensibly from American-born users such as “Robert Surgenor,” along with the claim that the images showed “Our Congress” hard at work:
Before this image collage was circulated by “American” social media accounts claiming that it showed “our Congress hard at work,” it was widely shared in Brazil where this collage has been circulating since at least 2015. It first went viral after it was reportedly posted to Whatsapp by Brazilian singer Tom Kléber. According to John Cutrim’s “Jornal Pequeno” the message was originally captioned “Êta povo que trabalha,” or “working for the people.”
We examined each of these five photographs to see if they truly showed Brazilian politicians sleeping on the job. And although these are all genuine photographs, we found that they showed isolated incidents that are not indicative of a poor work ethic in Brazil’s parliament when viewed in the correct context. The images showed legislative leaders dealing with extreme circumstances over the span of several years.
Another image shows Deputy Heráclito Fortes dozing off during a session analyzing presidential vetoes which started on a Tuesday night in September 2015 and finished near dawn the following morning.
Another one of the “sleeping politician” images was also taken during an overnight vote and showed Brazilian politician Iriny Lopes dozing off in December 2014:
The photographs included in this collage do not show politicians from the United States. Although these image truly do show Brazilian politicians momentarily napping on the job, these photographs were all taken in either extreme conditions (such as a hunger strike) or during marathon voting sessions.
Cutrim, John. “Cantor Tom Kleber Irrita Filho da Ex-Prefeita de Timon.”
Jornal Pequeno. 29 September 2015.
Campanerut, Camila. “Em Greve de Fome, Deputado Dorme em Primeiro Tempo Morno de Jogo do Brasil.”
UOL Noticias. 15 June 2010.
Sobrol Noticias. “Deputado Heráclito Fortes Dorme Durante Votação Contra Vetos da Presidente.”
24 September 2015.
Coletta, Ricardo. “Oposição já Admite Derrota Na Votação da MP Dos Portos.”
Estado. 16 May 2013.
Veja. “Cochilo, Biscoito e Colo: Uma Noite No Congresso.”
4 December 2014.