Did Cardinal George Pell Say Abortion Was Worse Than Sexual Abuse of Children?

The head of the Vatican's Secretariat for the Economy has declined to backtrack on his controversial July 2002 statement.

Claim

Cardinal George Pell, who has been charged with sexual abuse, once said that abortion was "a worse moral scandal than priests sexually abusing young people."

Rating

Origin

In 2018 an apparently defunct Instagram page highlighted the criminal charges against Cardinal George Pell, as contrasted with a controversial remark he made years earlier.

A graphic showed Pell, described as “the third-highest ranking official in the Vatican and currently charged with multiple counts of child sex abuse,” above a statement attributed to him holding that “Abortion is a worse moral scandal than priests sexually abusing young people”:

In this case, the graphic is accurate on all counts. Pell made the infamous statement during a World Youth Day event in July 2002, in reply to an American youth minister’s asking him how Catholics should respond to questions regarding the findings of systematic sexual abuse committed by church officials. When asked to explain his rationale, Pell (who at the time was the Archbishop of Sydney) said, “Because [abortion] is always a destruction of human life.”

The following month, Pell maintained that while the original reporting on his comment did not mention his condemnation of sexual abuse, he would not backtrack on the original statement:

I … mentioned that the church is being attacked for [sex abuse] sometimes by elements that are a bit anti-Christian … I said there are other scandals, such as abortion which are under-reported and because abortion destroys innocent life you could say it’s a worse scandal.

On 24 February 2014, Pell (who was by that point a cardinal) was appointed by Pope Francis to oversee the newly-created Secretariat for the Economy, granting Pell “authority over all economic and administrative activities” in the Vatican. Since then he has been described by multiple news outlets as being the Vatican’s third-highest ranking official.

Allegations of sexual abuse against Pell date to 2002, when he was accused of having molested a 12-year-old boy in 1961. An inquiry commissioned by the National Committee for Professional Standards, a group overseen by the Catholic Church of Australia, determined that the allegations were “unsubstantiated.”

But in June 2017, Pell was charged with historical sexual assault, a term used to an identify alleged offense that took place in the non-recent past. While some of those charges have been dismissed, on 1 May 2018 Pell was ordered to stand trial on other counts. He has pleaded not guilty.

  • Sydney Morning Herald.   "Pell Comes Under Fire from Sex Abuse Groups."     29 July 2002.
  • Sydney Morning Herald.   "I'll Say It Again, Abortion Is a Worse Evil: Pell."     3 August 2002.
  • Gibson, David.   "Pope Francis Overhauls Vatican Finances, Names Australian Cardinal as Comptroller."     The Washington Post.   24 February 2014.
  • Agence France-Press.   "Australian Catholic Archbishop in Abuse Row."     The Irish Times.   20 August 2002.
  • Sydney Morning Herald.   "Exonerated, Not Forgotten."     15 October 2002.
  • ABC News.   "George Pell, Catholic Cardinal, Charged with Historical Sexual Assault Offences."     29 June 2017.
  • BBC News.   "Cardinal Pell Ordered to Stand Trial on Sexual Assault Charges."     1 May 2018.

Dear Reader,

Snopes.com has long been engaged in the battle against misinformation, an effort we could not sustain without support from our audience. Producing reliable fact-checking and thorough investigative reporting requires significant resources. We pay writers, editors, web developers, and other staff who work tirelessly to provide you with an invaluable service: evidence-based, contextualized analysis of facts. Help us keep Snopes.com strong. Make a direct contribution today. Learn More.

Donate with PayPal