Claim: The Obama administration created a program to provide free cell phones to welfare recipients.
MIXTURE OF TRUE AND FALSE INFORMATION:
|TRUE: A federal program subsidizes providers who supply telephone services to low-income consumers.|
|FALSE: The Obama administration created a program to provide free cell phones and service to welfare recipients.|
[Collected via e-mail, October 2009]
Have you heard this one? THE OBAMAPHONE
Actually in the state of Wisconsin it is 250 minutes of Free Air Time and
they are running TV ads promoting it. No Bull
Just when you think you’ve heard it all,, our illustrious Congress
quietly comes up with a new zinger to put their hands in your pockets, and
pick them while you aren’t watching.
Isn’t this just wonderful!
I was standing in line at the checkout counter at Wal Mart and as I looked
at the line behind me, I saw a couple of people talking about what looked
like identical new cell phones, bragging about the fact that their phones
were free and so was the airtime.
The woman in line behind me had heard the same exchange and turned to the
young man behind her and asked, “Is that a new type of cell phone?”
The young man replied, “Yes, this is my new ‘Obama phone'”.
She asked him what an “Obama phone” was, and he went on to say that,
“Welfare recipients are now eligible to receive” what he described as (1)
a FREE new cell phone, and (2) approximately 70 FREE minutes of air time
Needless to say, I was a little skeptical about his answer, so when I got
back home, I ‘Googled’ it, and lo and behold, he was telling the truth.
This was what I discovered:
SafeLink Wireless is a government supported program that provides a free
cell phone and airtime each month for income-eligible customers.
In other words, your tax dollars are being distributed to a wireless phone
provider to provide welfare recipients with free cell phones and airtime.
I don’t know about you, but as for me, enough is enough. We are $14
Trillion in debt, Congress is balking at continuing unemployment payments
to those who want to work, and Congress is increasing the dole-out to dead
The ship of State is sinking, and it’s sinking fast. The old concept of
getting ahead through hard work has flown out the window. It has been
replaced by Obama’s and Congress’ idea of “Hope and Change.” The country
has changed all right, changed to “Why should I work for it, when I can
get it for free?”
[Collected via e-mail, October 2009]
Here’s another Obama program that we taxpayers are footing the bill for.
I had a former employee call me earlier today inquiring about a job, and at the end of the conversation he gave me his phone number. I asked the former employee if this was a new cell phone number and he told me yes this was his “Obama phone.” I asked him what an “Obama phone” was and he went on to say that welfare recipients are now eligible to receive
Origins: Imagine for a moment what your life would be like without a phone, corded or wireless. How would you contact emergency services if there was a fire or a serious injury? How would you contact a potential new employer, or keep in touch with a current one? How would you contact your utility company about a power outage, or a doctor about your sick child? How would you keep in touch with your loved ones and your community? In this day and age, telecommunications services are a real necessity, and not being able to afford them is a real liability.
Those types of questions prompted the Federal Communication Commission to implement the Lifeline benefit program for income-eligible consumers in 1984. That program had two parts: Lifeline Assistance, which
provided discounts on basic monthly landline telephone service at the primary residence of qualified telephone subscribers, and Lifeline Link-Up, which provided discounts on the initial installation fee for landline telephone service at the primary residence of qualified telephone subscribers.
As cell phone usage has increased and cell phone service fees have dropped, the Lifeline program has been expanded to include wireless technology. Prepaid cell phone companies have spun off government-approved subsidiaries (such as Safelink Wireless, Assurance Wireless, and Reachout Wireless) to specialize in providing Lifelife-covered telephone services to qualifying participants.
From that basic framework, rumors like the ones encapsulated in the Examples cited above have circulated, claiming that “the Obama administration created a program to give free cell phones paid for by taxpayer money to welfare recipients.” All the elements of such statements are erroneous or exaggerated:
- The Lifeline program originated in 1984, during the administration of Ronald Reagan; it was expanded in 1996, during the administration of Bill Clinton; and its first cellular provider service (SafeLink Wireless) was launched by TracFone in 2008, during the administration of George W. Bush. All of these milestones were passed prior to the advent of the Obama administration.
- The Lifeline program only covers monthly discounts on landline or wireless telephone service for eligible consumers. It does not pay
cellular companies to provide free cell phones to consumers, although some cellular service providers choose to offer that benefit to their Lifeline customers.
Lifelinediscounts are not available only to “welfare recipients” — these programs are implemented at both the state and federal levels, so qualification criteria can vary from state to state, but in general participants must have an income that is at or below 135% of the federal Poverty Guidelines, or take part in at least one of the following federal assistance programs:
- Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Food Stamps or SNAP);
- Supplemental Security Income (SSI);
- Federal Public Housing Assistance (Section 8);
- Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP);
- Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF);
- National School Lunch Program’s Free Lunch Program;
- Bureau of Indian Affairs General Assistance;
- Tribally-Administered Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TTANF);
- Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations (FDPIR);
- Head Start (if income eligibility criteria are met); or
- State assistance programs (if applicable).
- The Lifeline program is not directly subsidized by taxpayer monies. It is paid for out of the federal Universal Service Fund (USF) through a fee assessed against telecommunications service providers, who may or may not pass those costs along to their customers:
All telecommunications service providers and certain other providers of telecommunications must contribute to the federal USF based on a percentage of their interstate and international end-user telecommunications revenues. These companies include wireline phone companies, wireless phone companies, paging service companies and certain Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) providers.
Some consumers may notice a “Universal Service” line item on their telephone bills. This line item appears when a company chooses to recover its USF contributions directly from its customers by billing them this charge. The FCC does not require this charge to be passed on to customers. Each company makes a business decision about whether and how to assess charges to recover its Universal Service costs. These charges usually appear as a percentage of the consumer’s phone bill. Companies that choose to collect Universal Service fees from their customers cannot collect an amount that exceeds their contribution to the USF. They also cannot collect any fees from a Lifeline program participant.
The costs of administering the Lifeline program have increased greatly with the move towards cellular telephone services, leading the FCC to approve a comprehensive overhaul of the program in January 2012 intended to eliminate waste, fraud, and abuse.
A number of web sites touting Lifeline benefits and imitating the look of government web sites have sprung up on the Internet, but those sites are privately operated ones created to promote the sales of cellular services and have no official connection to the federal government or the current presidential administration:
By 2010, Virgin Mobile, Verizon, Sprint, i-Wireless, Head Start, Consumer Cellular, Midwestern Telecom, Allied Wireless, and others had free phone plans. That’s why you can find all these “free cell phone” websites that look kind of shady, like Obamaphone.net or FreeGovernmentCellPhones.net. In 2011, the FCC said that these carriers were “fiercely competing for the business of low-income consumers by marketing ‘free’ phones.” TracFone spokesman Jose Fuentes [said], “We’ve had a lot of fly-by-night companies come in.” Fuentes estimated that more than 1,700 wireless companies were part of Lifeline. Between 2008 and 2012, the number of people with Lifeline phones grew from 7.1 million to 12.5 million. These companies may be fly-by-night at providing cell phone service, but they are pretty good at marketing, and as the rush of merchandise tied to his inauguration showed, Obama’s name seems to move product.
|Affordable Telephone Service for Income-Eligible Consumers|
Last updated: 1 October 2012
Reeve, Elspeth. “The Obama Phone’s Roots in Government Deregulation.” The Atlantic. 2 October 2012. Businessweek. “FCC Trims Subsidy That Powers TracFone Amid Fraud Concern.” 2 February 2012. WSMV-TV [Nashville, TN]. “Low-Income Residents to Get Free Cell Phones.” 14 August 2008.