Social media brought the issue of sterilization surgery for women to the forefront with a graphic highlighting the relative difficulty patients can encounter seeking the procedure even if they meet the appropriate medical guidelines:
The meme contrasted the process of women undergoing tubal ligations — the process of closing a patient’s fallopian tubes and thus preventing sperm from entering them, more commonly called “getting your tubes tied” — with men obtaining vasectomies and includes a list of supposed requirements for women:
You must be 25, married, and have at least one son and daughter, and your husband must agree.
The statement was likely included as a dramatization rather than a literal recounting, reflecting the difficulties many women encounter when seeking the procedure. Physicians will sometimes decline to perform the procedure on women who are young (because they might regret the choice later on), who are childless or have an only child (because they might want more children), or whose partners/spouses are not involved or fully in accord with the decision.
In 2012 a New York woman, Monica Trombley, explained the opposition she faced from her own medical provider in an op-ed for Slate:
I got a tubal at 26 years old and had to fight to get one despite a) living in NYC, b) being married to a man as adamantly child-free as me, c) working in not one but two fields that are well-known for being unfriendly to kids (law and entertainment). The paternalistic treatment of doctors telling me they were going to “talk [me] out of it” still ticks me off (this happened in 2007) but what really took the cake was one doctor who outright lied to us about his willingness to respect my reproductive rights and our right to make decisions for our own family. He ended up changing his mind about doing the surgery and I found a specialist in Manhattan to do it after deciding I was going to lie about the circumstances for getting one.
In reality, there is no strict minimum age for adult patients seeking to undergo tubal ligations if they pay out of pocket or through private insurance plans. Patients using federally-funded insurance plans such as Medicaid, however, must be at least 21 years old and not “mentally incompetent”, and the procedure must take place at least 30 days after the patient has been “voluntarily given informed consent” regarding the process.
According to a report published in September 2016 by the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, coverage of the procedure’s costs varies from state to state:
Most states with a Family Planning waiver or SPA also cover the procedures for women, but there are exceptions. Ohio and Oregon do not cover tubal ligation (neither general nor post-partum) in their family planning programs. Connecticut, Georgia, Missouri, and Mississippi do not cover tubal ligation performed post-partum in their family planning programs, with Georgia noting that pregnant women are not enrolled in the state’s family planning waiver.
In April 2017, the ethics committee of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists advised members on the “Ethical Issues and Considerations” associated with sterilization of women:
It is ethically permissible to perform a requested sterilization in nulliparous [childless] women and young women who do not wish to have children. A request for sterilization in a young woman without children should not automatically trigger a mental health consulation. Although physicians understandably wish to avoid precipitating sterilization regret in women, they should avoid paternalism as well.
- Walls, Jenna et al. "Medicaid Coverage of Family Planning Benefits: Results from a State Survey." Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. 15 September 2016.
- Trombley, Monica. "No Kids for Me, Thanks: I Tied My Tubes at 26." Slate. 13 June 2012.
- American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. "Sterilization of Women: Ethical Issues and Considerations." April 2017.