Fact Check

Did a Cleveland Fox Affiliate Label a Black Murder Suspect 'Dark White'?

WJW-TV called a doctored screenshot of their news broadcast a "distraction."

Published Apr 17, 2017

Image Via WJW-TV
A Cleveland-area Fox affiliate described local murder suspect Steve Stephens as "dark white."

On 16 and 17 April 2017 Facebook users, pages, and blogs shared an image of a purported screenshot from a WJW-TV broadcast that described a black suspect as "dark white":

The viral image was part of a larger news story involving a manhunt for Cleveland resident Steve Stephens, accused of fatally shooting an elderly man on 16 April 2017. Stephens purportedly bragged about the murder on Facebook Live, subsequently claiming to have shot several additional victims. Cleveland.com reported:

Steve Stephens remained at-large early Monday morning, accused of a killing that unsettled Northeast Ohio and garnered national attention.

Police say Stephens, 37, of Cleveland, walked up to Robert Godwin Sr., a 74-year-old father of nine and grandfather of 14, on Sunday afternoon and fatally shot him on a sidewalk in the city's Glenville neighborhood.

Stephens posted a recording of the shooting on Facebook, then later posted another video laughing about the incident and claiming that he had killed more than a dozen other people.

Police said there is no evidence of other shooting victims.

The blog ClashDaily shared the doctored image in a 17 April 2017 post, claiming it was authentic:

‘DARK WHITE SKIN’: PC News Station Calls BLACK Facebook Killer WHITE

When a description of a suspect is given, political correctness shouldn’t EVER enter into it.

When the suspect is on the loose, armed, and threatening to murder random people, the goal is to get him into police custody.

And this guy live streamed a video saying he was going to commit murder on Facebook.

Steve Stephens, 37, is wanted for aggravated murder for the death of a senior citizen, Robert Godwin Sr., 74, of Cleveland.

On 16 April 2017, a Twitter user tweeted to the WJW-TV account to ask about the circulating photograph:

The news station confirmed that the image was doctored, providing the unaltered version side-by-side with the fake:

In a statement to Snopes.com, a representative for WJW-TV forwarded both versions of the image and confirmed:

There's an image circulating that shows "dark white" as the station's description of this Facebook Live suspect, but it's a pretty obvious photoshop fake. 

Steve Stephens remains at large as of 17 April 2017. 


Pinckard, Cliff.   "Cleveland Facebook Killing: Where We Stand Monday Morning."     Cleveland.com.   17 April 2017.

ClashDaily.com.   "‘Dark White Skin’: PC News Station Calls Black Facebook Killer White."     17 April 2017.

Kim LaCapria is a former writer for Snopes.

Read More

a Member

Your membership is the foundation of our sustainability and resilience.


Ad-Free Browsing on Snopes.com
Members-Only Newsletter
Cancel Anytime