Legend: A couple leaves their infant in the charge of a teenage, hippie-type girl while they go out on the town for the evening. When the mother phones home a few hours later to check up on things, the babysitter informs her that everything is fine and that she has put the turkey in the oven. A few moments later the couple recalls that they left no turkey at home; they rush home and find that the babysitter, high on LSD, has cooked their baby in the oven.
Example: Collected by Fowke, 1973]
This story was told to me by a friend who heard it on the news on the radio about a year or so ago. It is a factual account.
There was a girl and she was baby-sitting. The parents had gone out to a very big party and had left this infant at home with this sixteen-year-old girl. So she was babysitting and they phoned just to see if everything was all right. She said, “Oh, fine. Everything’s great. The turkey’s in the oven. The mother went, “Oh, okay, fine,” and she hung up. Then she looked at her husband and went, “The turkey’s in the oven? We didn’t have a turkey!” He said, “What’s the matter?” So they decided they had better go home and see what was the matter. Maybe there was something wrong with the babysitter.
They excused themselves from the party and went home. So they walked in the house and saw the baby-sitter sitting in the chair freaking out. She had put the little infant in the oven and had thought it was a turkey.
- The babysitter is a stranger to the couple, either because the parents have never left their child with a sitter before, or because the girl had just been recommended to them by friends or relatives.
- In most versions the baby is mistaken for a turkey by the sitter, but sometimes the girl tells the parents that their “roast” is done.
- The parents return home to find the hippie babysitter tripping on LSD, but other substances (such as marijuana and scotch) are sometimes mentioned.
urban legend probably circulated as a cautionary tale about the dangers of leaving children in the care of strangers before incorporating an additional warning against drug use in the 1960s. Brunvand, for example, cites a version collected by folklorist Lydia Fish in which drugs play no part:
After the parents left, the baby starting crying. No matter what the sitter did, the baby would not stop. After a time, the baby’s crying drove the sitter mad, and she put the kid in the oven and turned it up as high as it would go.
This tale was widely cited in the 1960s and 1970s as a “true story” illustrating the dangers of illicit drug use. As with the legend of Blue Star Acid, it contrasts evil drug users and innocent children, with the latter suffering harm due to the depredations of the former.
Other “cooked to death” legends include:
- The Cooked Telephone Man: Worker who stands too close to microwave radiation is cooked by its rays.
- The Microwaved Pet: Old lady attempts to dry a wet poodle in the microwave.
- Brown Betty: Bride trying to gain a fast tan prior to her wedding day cooks herself to death in commercial tanning beds.
Update: On 23 September 1999, aspects
of this chilling legend played out in real life when the body of
Lewis Martinez was discovered in the microwave of his parents’ home. His mother, Elizabeth Renee Otte (19) was arrested for his murder, but her representatives claimed she had been in a state of confusion at the time she folded her son in half, loaded him into the microwave, and powered it on. She’d had epileptic seizures before, and they speculated that while in the throes of one she mistook her child for a bottle of milk she was attempting to warm.
Some believed the scenario as described by Otte’s representatives to be plausible, but others saw the tragedy as yet another teenage mother murdering her baby, then claiming diminished capacity on whatever grounds she could come up with. After psychological and neurological exams undertaken to determine Otte’s competency to stand trial were completed, she pled no contest to involuntary manslaughter charges on
In November 2006, Ohio resident China Arnold was charged with the
Last updated: 6 October 2011
Also told in:
The Big Book of Urban Legends. New York: Paradox Press, 1994. ISBN 1-56389-165-4 (p. 62).