Fact Check

Gen. David Petraeus on the 0.45%

Gen. David Petraeus authored an essay about the 0.45% of the population that has served in the Global War on Terror?

Published Aug. 5, 2012


Claim:   Gen. David Petraeus authored an essay about the 0.45% of the population that has served in the Global War on Terror.


Example:   [Collected via e-mail, July 2012]

Some brief but very poignant (and appropriate) remarks from Gen David

I remember the day I found out I got into West Point.

My mom actually showed up in the hallway of my high school and waited for me to get out of class. She was bawling her eyes out and apologizing that she had opened up my admission letter. She wasn't crying because it had been her dream for me to go there. She was crying because she knew how hard I'd worked to get in, how much I wanted to attend, and how much I wanted to be an infantry officer. I was going to get that opportunity.

That same day two of my teachers took me aside and essentially told me the following: "David, you're a smart guy. You don't have to join the military. You should go to college, instead."

I could easily write a tome defending West Pont and the military as I did that day, explaining that USMA is an elite institution, that separate from that it is actually statistically much harder to enlist in the military than it is to get admitted to college, that serving the nation is a challenge that all able-bodied men should at least consider for a host of reasons, but I won't.

What I will say is that when a 16 year-old kid is being told that attending West Point is going to be bad for his future then there is a dangerous disconnect in America, and entirely too many Americans have no idea what kind of burdens our military is bearing.

In World War II, 11.2% of the nation served in four years. In Vietnam, 4.3% served in 12 years. Since 2001, only 0.45% of our population has served in the Global War on Terror. These are unbelievable statistics.

Over time, fewer and fewer people have shouldered more and more of the burden and it is only getting worse. Our troops were sent to war in Iraq by a Congress consisting of 10% veterans with only one person having a child in the military. Taxes did not increase to pay for the war. War bonds were not sold. Gas was not regulated. In fact, the average citizen was asked to sacrifice nothing, and has sacrificed nothing unless they have chosen to out of the goodness of their hearts.

The only people who have sacrificed are the veterans and their families. The volunteers. The people who swore an oath to defend this nation. You.

You stand there, deployment after deployment and fight on. You've lost relationships, spent years of your lives in extreme conditions, years apart from kids you'll never get back, and beaten your body in a way that even professional athletes don't understand. And you come home to a nation that doesn't understand. They don't understand suffering. They don't understand sacrifice. They don't understand that bad people exist. They look at you like you're a machine — like something is wrong with you. You are the misguided one — not them. When you get out, you sit in the college classrooms with political science teachers that discount your opinions on Iraq and Afghanistan because YOU WERE THERE and can't understand the "macro" issues they gathered from books with your bias. You watch TV shows where every vet has PTSD and the violent strain at that. Your Congress is debating your benefits, your retirement, and your pay, while they ask you to do more.

But the amazing thing about you is that you all know this. You know your country will never pay back what you've given up. You know that the populace at large will never truly understand or appreciate what you have done for them. Hell, you know that in some circles, you will be thought as less than normal for having worn the uniform. But you do it anyway. You do what the greatest men and women of this country have done since 1775 — YOU SERVED. Just that decision alone makes you part of an elite group.

Never in the field of human conflict has so much been owed by so many to so few.

You are the 0.45%.

General David Petraeus West Point Class 1974


Origins:   This essay about the sacrifices inherent in choosing to serve one's country through membership in the armed forces has been widely circulated as a piece written by Gen. David Petraeus, a four-star general who served in the United States Army for more than 37 years and since 2010 has been the director of the Central Intelligence Agency. Although Gen. David Petraeus is a 1974 graduate of the United States Military Academy at West Point, he had nothing to do with the authorship of this item.

Earlier circulated versions of this essay referenced the name "Nick" rather than "David" in the text, a clue to its actual author: Nick Palmisciano, co-owner and co-founder of Ranger Up. Nick reposted this essay on that site on 5 August 2012 to correct misattributions that variously credited it to General David Petraeus, General Norman Schwarzkopf, "A Marine in Iraq," and a host of others. In the body of his post, Nick explained the process by which his work was spread on the Internet:

1) I was talking over with Tom Amenta, my COO, about how the world has changed over the years relative to military service. We had the Occupy Movement as the backdrop.

2) At the end of our conversation, I sat down and wrote this essay and posted it to Ranger Up.

3) The US Army reposted it on their Facebook page, which was a huge honor for me. It received tens of thousands of likes in a day. They attributed the post to me at the bottom. This was a huge honor for me as I felt I had addressed the feelings of many service members. I write a lot, but I had never touched a chord with our community the way I had with this one.

4) In the next few weeks and months I started receiving spam letters or seeing incorrect blog posts attributing this essay to various people. The Ranger Up fans did such a great job of correcting people that I didn't get involved.

5) Now, there is an almost universal belief that General Petreous wrote this. It's on blogs. I've received many emails about how we "should post it."

So I'm posting it, again, just like I did when I wrote it.

Last updated:   5 August 2012

David Mikkelson founded the site now known as snopes.com back in 1994.

Article Tags