Fact Check

Teacher Fired for Praying in School During Oklahoma Tornado

Was an Oklahoma teacher fired for praying when a tornado hit her school?

Published May 26, 2013


Claim:   An Oklahoma teacher was fired for praying when a tornado hit her school.


Example:   [Collected via e-mail, May 2013]

Rumors are that an Oklahoma teacher was fired for praying during the tornado. Is this true?


Origins:   After a tornado wrought massive destruction in and around the town of Moore, Oklahoma, in May 2013, the news was full of accounts of survival and heroism, such as the story of Rhonda Crosswhite, an elementary school teacher who shielded some of her students with her body while praying for the twister to spare them:

Selfless teachers emerged from the wreckage of the tornado that ravaged Moore, Okla., as humble heroes who saved the lives of their terrified students.

Rhonda Crosswhite, a sixth-grade teacher at the Plaza Towers Elementary School, shielded three kids with her own body,

shouting over the roaring twister that everything would be okay as debris pelted her back.

Amid the schoolhouse chaos, Crosswhite never lost faith that she and her students would survive.

"The whole time I just kept screaming to them, 'Quit worrying, we're fine, we're fine," she said, adding that she was unsure if her attempts at reassurance could be heard over the twister.

"We're going to be fine, I'm protecting you," Crosswhite recalled telling the students. "Then I said a few prayers: 'God, please take care of my kids' — and we're fine."

The Palookaville Post used this event as the basis for a spoof on the controversial issue of school prayer, publishing an article headlined "Teacher Fired for Praying in School During Oklahoma Tornado" on 25 May 2013:

A teacher working at an Oklahoma school hit hard by a devastating tornado this week was fired after admitting she had prayed out loud during the horrific event, and that a complaint was filed by an atheist family of a kindergarten student who was offended by the Christian prayer.

Paulina Trumble, 52, a twenty three year veteran educator at Briarwood Elementary School in Moore, Oklahoma knew she was in trouble the moment the cyclone passed after realizing she had uttered out loud a prayer to the Almighty, violating strict separation of church and state laws.

"In a moment when I believed we were all going to die I naturally sought comfort from the only place I knew," said Trumble.

"I know prayer is strictly forbidden in classrooms, and the students know that too, but I’m only human and in the face of such terror I did break the rules. I’m sorry if I offended anyone or violated their civil rights."

By the following day links and excerpts referencing this article were being circulated via social media, with many of those who encountered the item mistaking it for a genuine news article. However, this item was just a bit of political humor from the Palookaville Post, a satirical web publication whose other recent spoofs include topics such as "Obamacare Plans to Sell List of Viagra Users to Match.com," "Obama Searches for Special White House Counsel on Craigslist," and "Feds Blame Ronald Reagan for Current Rise in Suicide Rate."

Nonetheless, the rumor that a teacher in Moore, Oklahoma, had been fired after praying for safety during the tornado became so prevalent that school officials took to the news media to debunk it, as described in the Tulsa World:

Moore Public School officials paused from their cleanup work to dispel an Internet rumor that a teacher had been fired for an audible prayer in school when [the] tornado hit.

No such school employee existed by the name circulated and no employees were fired, Superintendent Susan Pierce said.

"That's such a mean-spirited and disrespectful action," Pierce said at a news conference.

The rumor began that a teacher was fired because she lead the class in a prayer when the tornado barreled toward Moore on May 20.

Pierce said school officials checked out the rumor and found it to be false.

"I haven't stopped praying. We haven't stopped praying" since the storm, Pierce said. "We all turn to our beliefs and our faith in our time of crisis."

Last updated:   28 May 2013


    Wofford, Jerry.   "Moore Superintendent: No Teacher Was Fired for Praying."

    Tulsa World.   27 May 2013.

David Mikkelson founded the site now known as snopes.com back in 1994.

Article Tags