On 5 March 2019, a conspiracy-minded Twitter account shared a video purporting to be from the site of a construction project funded by West Virginia taxpayer money for the purpose of housing 321 Syrian refugees. The video also claimed this was being done at the expense of “regular” Americans who, the man claims, were being pushed into “substandard housing.” He asserted that the area he was standing in will be a “sharia zone,” and no non-Muslims will be allowed to enter:
Wow Unbelievable! Scary, who authorized this? BHO?#NotMe
What this guy is saying is frightening, it makes me feel like we've already lost the battle. How long can we hang on to our America.
We all need to #WakeUp now&smell the coffee
— KAGTrump Ewegot🚂🇺🇸⭐️⭐️⭐️ (@GregNorberg) March 6, 2019
Several factual problems exist with assertions in this video. Chief among them is the fact that this video shows the Littlepage Terrace housing project, a low-income, housing tax-credit property allocated through the West Virginia Housing Development Fund, which houses zero Syrian refugees and many “regular” Americans. Several lines of evidence support this conclusion. First, someone who works next to the project refers to it as Littlepage:
1) That’s Littlepage Terrace on the West Side of Charleston. It is a 2 min walk from my office.
2)The property has been subsidized housing since the 1940s and still is to this day.
3)There are no Syrians living there.
— C.A. Marino™️ (@CA_Marino1) March 6, 2019
4)The “Funeral Home” he points to and says being demolished is actually a Rite Aid. and it’s not being demolished.
5)The project cleaned up the west side and replaced buildings that were an eyesore.
Before and after pics of the project -Exact spot where video was filmed. pic.twitter.com/j6TRWz1Z3F
— C.A. Marino™️ (@CA_Marino1) March 6, 2019
Second, a wider, composite view of the man’s video shows clearly identifiable markers of the Littlepage housing complex, including a tell-tale smokestack and buildings that exactly match the structures built at Littlepage:
For comparison, here’s video shot at Littlepage:
Third, Mark Taylor, the chief executive officer of Charleston-Kanawha Housing Authority, which works with the Littlepage Terrace project, confirmed to us by email that the suspect video was taken at that site during renovations that likely occurred in May 2017. He also confirmed to us that the community houses no Syrian refugees.
Another significant oversight in the tweeted narrative is that the entire state of West Virginia has taken in far less than 321 Syrian refugees in total. In 2016, the year the United States took in the largest number of Syrian refugees, West Virginia resettled only five of them in their state. On 1 February 2017, the Trump Administration announced Executive Order 13769, commonly referred to as the “travel ban,” which indefinitely suspended the admission of Syrian refugees to the United States. In 2017, West Virginia took in 13 refugees, but these individuals were not necessarily Syrian.
It is true that Littlepage was torn down and rebuilt, but that decision had nothing to do with refugee housing. Instead, the renovations aimed to “reduce crime and revitalize the area,” as reported by West Virginia’s WCHS television station in 2016:
The Charleston-Kanawha Housing Authority is now on the last phase of revitalizing three housing projects. Similar to Orchard Manor and Washington Manor, Littlepage Terrace will be demolished and rebuilt as two-story town homes. … This housing project was built nearly 80 years ago with no air conditioning and poor visibility. Now it is simply not a secure living space. … The goal for these new developments is to reduce crime and revitalize the area.
Because the housing complex displayed was not built for Syrian refugees, and because the state has taken virtually no Syrian refugees at all, we rank the claims made in this video as aggressively and demonstrably false.
Charleston-Kanawha Housing. “Developments – Littlepage Terrace.”
Accessed 14 March 2019.
Zong, Jie, and Jeanne Batalova. “Syrian Refugees in the United States”
Migration Policy Institute. 17 January 2017.
Beck, Erin. “Few Syrian Refugees Resettle in WV, At Least for Now.”
Charleston Gazette-Mail. 2 September 2016.
Whitehouse.gov. “Executive Order Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States.”
27 January 2017.
U.S. Department of State. “Proposed Refugee Admissions for Fiscal Year 2019.”
24 September 2018.
Gunderson, Kaela. “Residents, Housing Officials Hope Littlepage Terrace Project Will Boost Safety.”
WCHS/WCAH ABC 8. 3 August 2016.