Claim:   U.S. active duty military deaths were higher during the administration of President Clinton than during the administration of George W. Bush.


Status:   False.

Example:   [Collected via e-mail, January 2008]




Surprise, Surprise (not really)

These are some rather eye-opening facts.

Since the start of the war on terror in Iraq and Afghanistan, the sacrifice has been enormous. In the time period from the invasion of Iraq in March 2003 through today, we have lost over 3,000 military personnel to enemy action and accidents.

As tragic as the loss of any member of the US Armed Forces is, consider the following statistics: The annual fatalities of military members while actively serving in the armed forces from 1980 through 2006:

1980 ……..2,392
1981 ……..2,380
1984 ……..1,999
1988 ……..1,819
1989 ……..1,636
1990 ……. 1,508
1991 ……..1,787
1992 ……..1,293
1993 ……..1,213
1994 ……..1,075
1995 ……..2,465
1996 ……..2,318
Clinton years @14,000 deaths
1997 ……….817
1998 ……..2,252
1999 ……..1,984
2000 ……..1,983
2001 ……… 890
2002 ……..1,007
2003 ……..1,410
2004 ……..1,887
2005 ……….919
2006………. 920
Bush years (2001-2006): 7,033 deaths

If you are confused when you look at these figures, so was I.

Do these figures mean that the loss from the two latest conflicts in the middle East are LESS than the loss of military personnel during Mr. Clinton’s presidency; when America wasn’t even involved in a war? And, I was even more confused; when I read that in 1980, during the reign of President (Nobel Peace Prize winner) Jimmy Carter, there were 2,392 US military fatalities!

These figures indicate that many members of our Media and our Politicians will pick and choose. They present only those “facts” which support their agenda-driven reporting. Why do so many of them march in lock-step to twist the truth? Where do so many of them get their marching-orders for their agenda?

(These statistics are published by Congressional Research Service, and they may be confirmed by anyone at: http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RL32492.pdf )



Origins:   What a muddle one can make of statistics.

The item quoted above attempts to demonstrate that — despite the criticism of President George W.

Bush for involving the U.S. in wars in Afghanistan and Iraq — U.S. active duty military deaths were actually significantly higher during the administration of his predecessor, President Bill Clinton. However, the proffered list of statistics is seriously flawed, as it grossly exaggerates the yearly loss figures for years corresponding to the presidency of Bill Clinton and under reports them for the years corresponding to the presidency of George W. Bush.

The numbers reproduced in this piece were taken from a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report on American War and Military Operations Casualties, using Table 4 on page 10, that presents statistics for U.S. active duty military deaths for the period 1980-2006.(Table 5, which separates combat/operational losses from deaths due to other causes — accident, homicide, illness, suicide — would have been a better source, but since the item quoted above used Table 4 to document its claim, so do we here.)

We find the following totals in that CRS report:





































































































































































































YearPresidentDeathsTotal during presidency
1980Jimmy Carter2,392
N/A
1981Ronald Reagan2,380
1982Ronald Reagan2,319
1983Ronald Reagan2,465
1984Ronald Reagan1,999
1985Ronald Reagan2,252
1986Ronald Reagan1,984
1987Ronald Reagan1,983
1988Ronald Reagan1,819
17,201
1989George H.W. Bush1,636
1990George H.W. Bush1,507
1991George H.W. Bush1,787
1992George H.W. Bush1,293
6,223
1993Bill Clinton1,213
1994Bill Clinton1,075
1995Bill Clinton1,040
1996Bill Clinton974
1997Bill Clinton817
1998Bill Clinton827
1999Bill Clinton796
2000Bill Clinton758
7,500
2001George W. Bush891
2002George W. Bush999
2003George W. Bush1,228
2004George W. Bush1,874
2005George W. Bush1,942
2006George W. Bush1,858
8,792

Even though the CRS table does not include loss figures for the last two years of George W. Bush’s presidency, the total number of U.S. military losses that have occurred during his administration is already significantly higher than the equivalent figure for Bill Clinton’s presidency (8,792 vs. 7,500). When active duty deaths for 2007 and 2008 are factored in (the Pentagon has not yet released figures for these two years, but the U.S. suffered 1,014 war deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan in 2007 and at least another 100 so far in 2008), the discrepancy is even greater.

When we consider all the information in this table, we also find that the number of active duty losses during the Clinton presidency was less than half the number that occurred during the Reagan presidency, and only about 20% higher than the number that occurred during the George H.W. Bush presidency (even though Clinton served as president for twice as long as the elder Bush).

Last updated:   26 March 2008

 



  SourcesSources:

    Vinch, Chuck.   “E-Mail on Military Deaths Is Shaky on Facts.”

    Army Times.   25 March 2008.


More From Snopes.com

Loading...