Fact Check

Fourever Fortune

A wealthy woman left her entire estate to a man she had met only once, and spent a total of four hours with.

Published Jul 26, 2007

A wealthy woman left her entire estate to a man she had met only once, and spent a total of four hours with.

A common form of "instant wealth" legend involves a person who receives a large, unexpected inheritance from a wealthy benefactor — someone with whom the recipient has had only brief, incidental contact, but during that fleeting moment performed a kindness later rewarded in spades. Examples of this motif include the tale of a man who engages in a one-night stand with the widowed owner of a country inn and several months later finds out she has left him both the inn and a tidy sum of money in her will, and the legend of the traveler who casually stumbles upon a stranger's funeral and afterwards learns that the deceased was a wealthy man who decreed that his fortune should be divided among all those who attended his final services.

That stories of this ilk are familiar urban legends doesn't mean they don't occasionally play out in real life, however. One such case occurred in 1951, when Margaret Jorgenson, a divorced dressmaker from Oshkosh, Wisconsin, died at the age of 66 and left behind a will bequeathing her entire estate, valued at the then-considerable sum of $97,864 (over $1 million in 2019 dollars) to one Joseph Kogut.

Who was Joseph Kogut? He was an unmarried, 41-year-old New York Central railroad inspector from Cuyler, New York, whom Miss Jorgenson had randomly encountered in a Chicago hotel elevator one day in November 1950 when Kogut was in the Windy City on business. The two struck up a conversation over the headline of a newspaper Miss Jorgenson was carrying that day (about the victory of Everett Dirksen in the previous day's election for one of Illinois' U.S. Senate seats), had lunch together, and then went their separate ways after spending a total of about four hours together. Apart from that one encounter, they never saw or spoke to each other again (although they did carry on a correspondence by mail).

Before Miss Jorgenson died several months later, she made out a will naming Mr. Kogut as her sole beneficiary. Her disgruntled relatives (two brothers and a sister, whom Jorgenson had left out of her will because she felt they had neglected her) contested the will, claiming that Mr. Kogut had "exercised undue influence" on Miss Jorgenson. Three years later the siblings finally agreed to a settlement that paid each of them $16,000 and awarded the remainder of Margaret Jorgenson's estate (estimated at $40,000 after taxes, or about $400,000 in 2019 dollars) to Joseph Kogut.


The New York Times.   "Woman Left $40,000 to Friend of 4 Hours."     13 November 1954   (p. 9).

Traverse City Record-Eagle.   "Visited Four Hours at $10,000 per Hour."     11 November 1954   (p. 10).

David Mikkelson founded the site now known as snopes.com back in 1994.