Does a Picture Show a Shanty Town in Los Angeles?

U.S. President Donald Trump has criticized California for its homeless population, but an alleged image of L.A. got some things wrong.

  • Published
Image via Facebook

Claim

An image shows a village of shacks in Los Angeles in 2019.

Rating

Miscaptioned
Miscaptioned
About this rating

Origin

U.S. President Donald Trump visited Los Angeles, California, on Sept. 18, 2019, and an image containing false information about the West Coast city circulated on social media around the same time.

The picture appears to have initially been published in 2015 by the British Daily Mail tabloid, which reported at that time it showed “shacks” that had been “built by gypsies” in Paris, France. The article decried the building of “shanty town” villages in one of “Europe’s great cities,” even as human rights groups pointed out that Roma people are European Union citizens.

During his visit to California, Trump struck a similar tone, criticizing California for an ongoing housing crisis and stating that homeless people are occupying “our best highways, our best streets, our best entrances to buildings.”

California’s major cities are indeed experiencing a rise in homelessness, driven largely by a lack of affordable housing. But the above image does not depict Los Angeles, nor was it taken in 2019. Therefore we rate this claim “Miscaptioned.”

  • Published
Sources

Stanton, Jenny. “The Third World Shanty Town… in the Heart of Paris: Roma Gypsies Create Their Own Village Built from Rubbish and Scrap in One of Europe’s Great Cities.”
  Daily Mail. 18 December 2015.

Oreskes, Benjamin, et al.. “Trump Says California Cities ‘Destroying Themselves’ With Homelessness.”
  Los Angeles Times. 17 September 2019.

Siegler, Kirk. “California Experiences an Alarming Spike in Homelessness.”
  NPR. 16 April 2018.