Did CBS News Use a 2016 Ukraine Photo in COVID-19 Coverage?

Unverified, random tweets are not regarded as reliable sources by real journalists.

  • Published
Image via CBS News screenshot

Claim

CBS News tried to pass off a photograph taken in Ukraine in 2016 as a picture of a U.S. child afflicted with a coronavirus-related disease in 2020.

Rating

Origin

Snopes is still fighting an “infodemic” of rumors and misinformation surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, and you can help. Find out what we’ve learned and how to inoculate yourself against COVID-19 misinformation. Read the latest fact checks about the vaccines. Submit any questionable rumors and “advice” you encounter. Become a Founding Member to help us hire more fact-checkers. And, please, follow the CDC or WHO for guidance on protecting your community from the disease.

On May 24, 2020, the notoriously unreliable Gateway Pundit website published an article claiming that a “CBS Evening News” report about a “mystery illness possibly tied to COVID-19” affecting children in the New York City area deceptively used a 2016 photograph showing a child from Ukraine suffering from a coxsackievirus infection:

Gateway Pundit’s claim was entirely wrong. The photograph that the site claimed was a 2016 picture depicting an infant in Ukraine suffering from a coxsackievirus infection had actually been posted online several years earlier, in a 2009 blog entry about the use of steroids in treating children with Kawasaki’s disease. That picture obviously wasn’t taken in 2016, and the blog post in which it appeared made no reference to Ukraine or coxsackievirus:

Moreover, the CBS News report did not in any way make deceptive use of this image by wrongly presenting it as a picture of a child being treated in New York City in 2020, as Gateway Pundit falsely suggested. The report simply used the photograph as a visual example of what Kawasaki symptoms look like by briefly displaying it while the narrator mentioned that the unknown illness currently “putting otherwise healthy children in the hospital” in New York City during the COVID-19 pandemic “resembles Kawasaki disease”:

 
It appears that, with their usual disregard for journalistic standards, Gateway Pundit relied upon an unverified third-party tweet to issue a baseless accusation, without making any attempt whatsoever to verify the content of that tweet or the source(s) on which it was based.

  • Published
Sources

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.   “Kawasaki Disease.”
    Accessed 25 May 2020.

Hoecker, Jay L., M.D.   “Coxsackievirus in Children: How serious Is It?”
    Mayo Clinic.   19 July 2017.

LaPook, Jon.   “Kids Hospitalized with Mystery Illness Possibly Tied to COVID-19.”
    CBS Evening News.   5 May 2020.

i steroids.   “Children with Kawasaki’s Disease Can Benefit from Steroids.”
    23 November 2009.

Hoft, Jim.   “CBS Caught Using Photo from Ukraine in 2016 in Their ‘Panic Porn’ on Coronavirus in Children.”
    Gateway Pundit.   24 May 2020.