Claim: President George W. Bush waved at blind musician Stevie Wonder at the 2002 Presidential Gala.
Example: [Collected via e-mail, March 2002]
When Stevie Wonder sat down at the keyboard center stage, President Bush in the front row got very excited. He smiled and started waving at Wonder, who understandably did not respond. After a moment Bush realized his mistake and slowly dropped the errant hand back to his lap.
"I know I shouldn't have," a witness told us yesterday, "but I started laughing."
Origins: This anecdote about President Bush supposedly waving at blind musician Stevie Wonder appeared in the pages of The
reached an even larger audience through the medium of television via Late Night with Conan O'Brien and Saturday Night Live.
Was it true? Well, not really. Although Stevie Wonder did perform at the
After running the item as true and being challenged upon it by the Ford's Theatre Artistic Director, who was seated by the President that night and didn't at all recall this incident, Washington Post writer Lloyd Grove delved further into the story. Editors working on turning film of that event into a television special went frame by frame through the video captured by the "presidential isocam" (as the camera trained on Bush is called). At the point where Wonder was getting settled behind his keyboard, Bush briefly raised his palm and smiled. The gesture was not the excited, enthused wave it is now comically portrayed to be; it was a small motion of the sort one routinely makes to an acquaintance across a crowded room. Moreover, the motion appears to have been directed at Kelsey Grammer, the emcee of the evening.
Stories that showcase blockheadedness stick to
And yet, even if the story had been true, even if President Bush had waved at a blind man,
People who can see and who have good hearing react to the world around them in the manner they are accustomed to. Our methods of greeting those we encounter are so deeply ingrained that the sighted and hearing don't think twice about them — a hand goes up or a name gets called out while we're still on autopilot. The realization that the person being waved to couldn't have seen the gesture only begins to sink in when the one offering the greeting fails to get the expected wave in return and starts wondering if his friend is peeved with him. Likewise, only when "Bob, hey Bob; over here!" fails to provoke a response does the shouter remember that his friend is deaf.
George W. Bush may or may not be a brilliant man, but this "waving at Stevie Wonder" anecdote would fail to prove anything, even if it were true. However, like the "Hillary throws a lamp" tale (which supposedly offered confirmation that she is an evil-tempered virago via an illustrative story about her pitching a lamp at Bill's head), this story is likely to trail after President Bush for as long as he's in office and for years beyond that. We like our caricatures drawn with simple lines, after all.
Barbara "receiving line" Mikkelson
Last updated: 30 May 2014
Dempster, Nigel. "Bush's Eye for Detail." Daily Mail. 7 March 2002 (p. 43). Grove, Lloyd and Barbara Martinez. "One Toke Over the Harvard Line?" The Washington Post. 6 March 2002 (p. C3). Grove, Lloyd. "Hey, Pundits, Don't Blame Us!" The Washington Post. 12 March 2002 (p. C3).