Fact Check

Were Bahamians Fleeing Dorian Told to Leave a Ferry to Florida Because They Lacked Visas?

The answer had to do with confusion and miscommunication rather than new visa requirements.

Published Sep 10, 2019

Evacuees get off a ferry after leaving Marsh Harbour on Abaco island in the aftermath of hurricane Dorian in Nassau, Bahamas on September 9, 2019. - President Donald Trump said Monday that the US would have to be careful about allowing Bahamian survivors of Hurricane Dorian into the country, warning there could be "very bad people" among them. The previous day, several hundred storm survivors were prevented from boarding a ferry from the Bahamas to Florida because they lacked US visas -- an incident that a top American immigration official said was a mistake. (Photo by ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS / AFP) (Photo credit should read ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS/AFP/Getty Images) (ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS/AFP/Getty Images)
Bahamians fleeing the destruction of Hurricane Dorian in late summer 2019 were forced to leave a boat to the U.S. because they didn't have visas.
What's True

Dozens of Bahamians who were fleeing Hurricane Dorian were told to get off a ferry boat headed to the U.S. if they didn't have travel visas.

What's False

The incident was the result of a lack of communication between the ferry operator and U.S. immigration authorities, not a result of a new U.S. policy requiring Bahamians to have such visas.

Reports that Bahamians without travel visas were being ordered to disembark from a ferry headed to the U.S. after Hurricane Dorian hit the Bahaman islands in September 2019 prompted some readers to question whether the Trump administration's harsh stance on immigration had seeped into Hurricane Dorian relief efforts with the imposition of new entry requirements. But the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agency blamed the incident on the ferry operator's failure to coordinate with U.S. authorities as requested.

The incident of Sept. 8, 2019, was captured on video by WSVN reporter Brian Entin, who posted it via his Twitter account. In the video, a voice can be heard on the loudspeaker of a ferry docked in Freeport, Bahamas, which was getting ready to transport Dorian evacuees to Florida, instructing passengers lacking U.S. visas to disembark:

The video raised questions about whether the Trump administration had implemented a new policy requiring Bahamians traveling to the U.S. to possess travel visas, even as they were fleeing the impacts of a hurricane that left several dozen of their fellow residents dead. President Donald Trump himself added to the confusion with remarks that made it appear he was cracking down on Bahamian-storm evacuees.

But CBP officials rushed to clarify that was not the case.

The agency released a statement saying that CPB "was notified of a vessel preparing to embark an unknown number of passengers in Freeport and requested that the operator of the vessel coordinate with U.S. and Bahamian government officials in Nassau before departing The Bahamas."

CBP noted in their statement that 1,500 other evacuees had arrived in Florida and were processed smoothly the day prior to the incident captured on video. Entin interviewed officials from CBP in Florida once the ferry arrived, who said that had the ferry operator, Balearia Caribbean, coordinated with them, the problem could have been avoided:

We reached out to Balearia Caribbean for comment and did not receive a response. However, the company did issue an apology, with CNN quoting them as saying, "We boarded these passengers with the understanding that they could travel to the United States without visas, only to later [be] advised that in order to travel to Ft. Lauderdale they required prior in-person authorization from the immigration authorities in Nassau."

Many Bahamians don't need travel visas to enter the U.S. and can receive clearance prior to traveling if they meet certain requirements, including possession of a valid passport and lack of a criminal record. In the aftermath of the incident, acting CBP Commissioner Mark Morgan took to Twitter to clarify that this situation has not changed:

Morgan further stressed during a press conference that CBP was engaged in a humanitarian mission in the Bahamas: "If your life is in jeopardy and you’re in the Bahamas ... you’re going to be allowed to come to the United States, whether you have travel documents or not."


Licon, Adriana Gomez.   "Florida-Bound Evacuees from Bahamas Asked to Get Off Ferry."     Associated Press.   9 September 2019.

Shepherd, Katie and Herman Wong.   "Trump Speaks Out After Bahamas Hurricane Survivors Were Kicked Off Ferry Over U.S. Visa Demands."     The Washington Post.   9 September 2019.

Maxouris, Christina, et al.   "Ferry Operator Apologizes After Dozens of Bahamian Evacuees Were Told to Get Off a Ferry Headed to the US."     CNN.   10 September 2019.

Berry, Deborah Barfield and Alan Gomez.   "Tiny Shoes, Caged Children: Protesting Trump Administration 'Zero Tolerance' Immigration Policy."     USA Today.   7 May 2019.

Bethania Palma is a journalist from the Los Angeles area who started her career as a daily newspaper reporter and has covered everything from crime to government to national politics. She has written for ... read more

Article Tags