One of the many heart-breaking images to emerge from the 14 February 2018 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, was that of Andrew Pollack.
Pollack was photographed by the Palm Beach Post, holding up a cellphone picture of his 18-year-old daughter Meadow, as he waited in his car outside a Broward County hospital, unable to reach Meadow by phone, and fearing the worst.
The reporter who spoke to Pollack, Alexandra Seltzer, later confirmed on Twitter that Meadow had died, one of the 17 victims of a mass shooting carried out by Nikolas Cruz, a former pupil of the high school.
— Alexandra Seltzer (@alexseltzer) February 15, 2018
According to the right-wing Daily Wire web site, what happened next was that “intolerant and hateful leftists attacked a man whose daughter was murdered in the shooting because he is a Trump supporter.”
In a viral Facebook post, Amy Le Chet wrote:
This is Andy. His daughter Meadow was murdered in the Douglas HS shooting on 2-14-18. He is being attacked on social media for being a Trump supporter. Please show him your love and support.
We received enquiries about the authenticity of the tweets quoted by the Daily Wire, and the veracity of claims that Pollack was attacked online for wearing a “Trump 2020” t-shirt.
It is true that a relatively small number of people on Twitter did criticize Pollack on the grounds of his support for President Donald Trump, and one or two went out of their way to articulate their lack of sympathy for him, and even to blame him for his own daughter’s death.
The tweets quoted in the Daily Wire’s article are authentic, and not fabricated.
However, a far greater number expressed sympathy for the grieving father, and criticized those speaking against him.
Furthermore, these comments were not addressed directly to Pollack, who does not appear have a Twitter account.
On Facebook, we trawled through hundreds of comments posted to Pollack’s page in the aftermath of his daughter’s death. We found just two comments critical of Donald Trump and arguably insensitive to Pollack’s grief, but not one personal attack directly addressed to Pollack himself.
On the contrary, Facebook users posted hundreds of messages expressing sympathy, condolences, solidarity and support towards Pollack and his family.
As is often the case with social networking controversies and disputes, the outraged response to an offense (the public slating of Andrew Pollack for his political beliefs) has been vastly greater than the scale of the offense itself.
Pollack and members of his family visited the White House on 21 February 2018, to take part in a “listening session” hosted by President Trump.
Pollack delivered powerful remarks, at times directly addressing Trump, saying “I’m very angry that this happened, because it keeps happening.”
Seltzer, Alexandra. “Broward School Shooting: Family Says Missing Girl Meadow Pollack Has Died.”
Palm Beach Post. 14 February 2018.