Extremely Low Overhead

A number of articles inaccurately reported that United Airlines would begin charging passengers for the use of overhead bins on flights.

Everything I Do / ShutterStock

Claim: United Airlines will begin charging for overhead bin space.

mostly false

WHAT'S TRUE: United Airlines introduced a fare class called "Basic Economy," which permits one personal item, but restricts an additional carry-on bag.

WHAT'S FALSE: No portion of the fare's terms restricts the use of overhead bins; the luggage restriction applies only to a small class of travelers opting in to the fare.

Example: [Collected via Facebook and e-mail, December 2016]

Is United Airlines going to charge a fee for overhead bin use?


So glad you folks added a charge for using overhead compartments. Finally, the vast majority of us who don't travel with luggage are free from subsidizing that burdensome few who do.


Your decision to create a class of service that does not include use of overhead bins is reprehensible. I see that estimates are that you will see a billion dollars of extra revenue from passengers who have to pay to check luggage who must choose higher fares to include luggage or pay a checked luggage fee when they might have been able to carry on their luggage. I doubt very seriously that your budget economy seats will be sold at the low fares one sees from the low cost European airlines where one expects fees for anything beyond the fare. And even those airlines don't charge for use of overhead bins for goodness sakes. As a former status holder on United and every other major US airline, you've long held my prize for worst customer focus and service. And you continue to earn it with these policies.

Origin:On 6 December 2016, articles appeared reporting that the days of free overhead bins on United Airlines are over, in yet another cost-cutting measure for the company:

Gone are the days of the free sandwiches, the complimentary pillows, the headphones that didn’t cost $5. The in-flight comforts that were once a given are now nothing more than a nostalgic reminder of decades past.

Out went the free checked bag, in came the fees for those few extra inches of leg room. Want to make sure you sit next to your children on a flight? On some airlines, there’s a fee for that.

Now, on United Airlines, you won’t necessarily get the use of an overhead bin without paying more money.

The overhead bin: “one of the last sacred conveniences of air travel,” as an angry Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) put it Sunday as he denounced the move.

 

Although both articles noted in the body text that the airline might charge a fee, or that the claim was part of a new ticket option, attention-grabbing headlines were all that many people spotted. Rumors quickly kicked up suggesting that United Airlines was in the process of implementing a specific "overhead bin" fee applicable to all passengers:  

Representatives on social media explained that the claims were inaccurate:

The outcry appeared to stem from the introduction of a new fare class called "Basic Economy," an optional form of ticketing with some restrictions:

While Basic Economy fares have some important, additional restrictions compared to standard Economy fares, customers will enjoy the same United Economy® cabin experience and services, including dining options, Wi-Fi and inflight entertainment. However, the following differences do apply:
• Automated seat assignments will be given at check-in, and passengers acknowledge at the point of a multi-seat purchase that seating together is not guaranteed.
Carry-on bags are limited to one personal item, unless the customer is a MileagePlus® Premier® member, primary cardmember of a qualifying MileagePlus credit card, or Star AllianceTM Gold member.
• There will be no voluntary ticket changes except as stated in the United 24-hour flexible booking policy.
• MileagePlus program members will earn redeemable award miles; however they will not earn Premier qualifying credit (miles, segments, or dollars), no lifetime miles, and no contribution to four segment minimum.
• Customers will not be eligible for Economy Plus® or premium cabin upgrades.
• Customers will board in the last boarding group (currently Group 5) unless a MileagePlus Premier member, primary cardmember of a qualifying MileagePlus credit card, or Star Alliance Gold member.

The restrictions imposed in the optional new class of fare pared the traditional "carry on and a personal item" down to one personal item. However, no restriction was imposed on placing that item in the overhead bin.  United noted that the fare is one flyers can select, but travelers still have the option of choosing a fare with additional baggage included:

We contacted United via Twitter and e-mail, but have not yet received a response.

Originally published: 07 December 2016

Featured Image: Everything I Do / ShutterStock

sources:

Keenan, Bretton.   "United Airlines Will Charge Extra Fee For Use Of Overhead Bins."
    WMAR.   5 December 2016.

Schmidt, Samantha.   "No More Free Overhead Bin On United: Is An Extra Fee For Oxygen Next?"
    Washington Post.   6 December 2016.

United Airlines: Travel information; Inflight services.   "Basic Economy."
      Accessed 7 December 2016.



Kim LaCapria is a New York-based content manager and longtime snopes.com message board participant. Although she was investigated and found to be "probably false" by snopes.com in early 2002, Kim later began writing for the site due to an executive order unilaterally passed by President Obama during a secret, late-night session (without the approval of Congress). Click like and share if you think this is an egregious example of legislative overreach.



Snopes