Claim: The National Football League enjoys tax-exempt status as a nonprofit organization.
|FALSE: The billions of dollars in profits made by the NFL's
|TRUE: The NFL League Office was a tax-exempt entity up until 2015.|
Example: [Collected via e-mail, February 2015]
Today is Super Bowl Sunday. For those who don’t follow professional football, this is the league’s championship game and the biggest sporting event on the American sports calendar.
The National Football League, like other sports leagues, is a major money-maker. Every year, the NFL pulls in somewhere close to $10 BILLION. The League's goal is to make $25 BILLION a year by 2027.
Here's the thing: The NFL doesn't pay Federal taxes. That's because it is technically classified as a non-profit corporation.
Origins: In September 2014, amid controversy over the National Football League's (NFL) handling of domestic abuse cases involving some of its players, Senator Cory Booker of
It is true that the NFL, a sports league that generates an estimated
Claims that the NFL is using a tax exemption to avoid paying the tax due on these revenues are simply misinformed. The confusion arises from the fact that there is one small part of the NFL, unrelated to all this business activity, that is tax-exempt: the NFL League Office. The league office is the administrative and organizational arm of the NFL and does things like write the rules of the game, hire referees, run the college draft, negotiate the collective bargaining agreement with the players, conduct player safety research, and run youth football programs.
The league office acts as a trade association for the NFL clubs. In the same way that other trade associations support companies in other lines of business, it establishes rules and standard practices for its members, develops programs to help them run their operations more efficiently and profitably, and promotes the business in the broader community. Trade associations are nonprofit organizations. They don;t engage in any business activity. As a result, they are exempt from being taxed under section 501(c)(6) of the federal tax code. (Charities are exempt under section 501(c)(3); the NFL League Office has never claimed to be a charity.)
Because the league office does not receive income from game tickets, television contracts and the like, its tax exemption does not apply to any of the profits earned in the NFL overall. All the money-making activity is conducted by the
The NFL was first bestowed with its tax-exempt status in 1942, when the league was struggling financially amidst the entry of the U.S. into World
Some critics have maintained that the NFL (and the NFL alone, not other sports leagues) is tax-exempt due to a special "loophole" inserted into the tax code in 1966, referencing Section 501(c)(6) of the IRS code, a section that specifically includes "Professional football leagues" along with "business leagues, chambers of commerce, real-estate boards, or boards of trade" as tax-exempt organizations. However, the NFL had been afforded tax-exempt status well before that modification was made; the change was undertaken solely to allow the merger of the NFL and AFL (American Football League) to go forward without fear of an antitrust challenge under either the Clayton Antitrust Act or the Federal Trade Commissions Act:
Still, some critics maintain that the NFL should never have been granted tax-exempt status in the first place, much less have been allowed to maintain it for so long, as the league is neither an "open" industry nor one that works towards the greater good of its industry or the public at large:
The problem is that the NFL should never have been considered a trade association in the first place. Love or hate the lobbying they do in Washington, trade groups are supposed to work for the benefit of entire industries, and be open to any business in that industry that would like to join. If you own a butter-making factory, then by God, you can pay dues and become a member of the American Butter Institute. The NFL, in contrast, operates a legally sanctioned sports cartel. It's not in the league's interest to let in more teams, because that could hurt the value of existing franchises.
If NFL executives were out lobbying on behalf of college football teams or arena football, we might have a different story. But they're not. The league office is the enforcement wing and rule-making body of a profit-making operation. The same goes for leagues like the NHL, which exist for the express purpose of excluding competition.
The deeper issue at play here is that nonprofits exist to do things for the public good — things that for-profit companies generally don't do. That's why we give nonprofits a break from the IRS. And it's why the government should be stingy about which kinds of organizations count and which don't. We know that sports leagues won't suddenly disappear if we treat them like normal corporations and ask them to pay, at most, a few million dollars to the government. Major League Baseball certainly hasn't gone anywhere. The NFL won't either.
In April 2015, however, the NFL announced the league office would be giving up its status as a tax-exempt organization:
In a letter to team owners, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell said the move addresses a misunderstanding about the tax status of the $10 billion-a-year organization. The central league office, which coordinates and manages the league's affairs, is listed as a nonprofit organization, but the NFL's 32 teams already pay taxes on their profits, as well as on player salaries and merchandise sales.
"The effects of the tax-exempt status of the league office have been mischaracterized repeatedly in recent years," Mr. Goodell said in the letter. "The fact is that the business of the NFL has never been tax-exempt."
Mr. Goodell said that the league office and its management council will file returns as taxable entities for the 2015 fiscal year, adding that the change won't affect "in any way" the function or operation of the league.
However, by forgoing its tax-exempt status, the NFL will no longer be required to disclose the salaries of its commissioner and other top executives. Mr. Goodell received $35 million in salary and bonuses in 2013.
Last updated: 28 August 2015
Clegg, Jonathan. "NFL to End Tax-Exempt Status." The Wall Street Journal. 28 April 2015. Peter, Josh. "Critics Question League's Tax-Exempt Activities." New Orleans Times-Picayune. 14 July 2002. Spector, Jeremy. "Don't Strip Away the NFL's Tax Exempt Status." U.S. News & World Report. 30 November 2013. Tracy, Marc. "Bill Targets Pro Sports Leagues' Tax-Exempt Status." The New York Times. 16 September 2014. Weissman, Jordan. "The NFL Is Not a Nonprofit." Slate. 18 September 2014.