E-mail this page E-mail this




Desk Job

Claim:   Photograph shows President Obama "desecrating" the Oval Office by placing his feet on his desk.

REAL PHOTOGRAPH;
INACCURATE DESCRIPTION

Examples:   [Collected via e-mail, February 2010]

Does this photo taken in the Oval Office convey anything to you about attitude and arrogance?

Would you speak with the Chief of Staff, your Chief Economics Adviser, and your Senior Adviser with your feet up on the Resolute Desk - a gift from Queen Victoria to President Rutherford B. Hayes in 1880?

We should inundate the White House with emails demanding that he stop desecrating his office and keep his feet off of our furniture.

This arrogant, immature, self-centered idiot demonstrates repeatedly that he has no sense of honor, or of simple decency.

While this posture is disrespectful in any culture, it is absolutely never done in any executive setting.

Further, in over half of the cultures of the world, it is recognized not only as disrespectful, but as an extreme insult to show the bottom of your shoes. In some cultures it could also get you killed!

He thinks of himself as a king -- and not as a servant of the people, humbly occupying our White House for his term in office.

Electing him was an enormous mistake -- and will cost us in many ways, for generations



 

Origins:   The above-displayed image is a photograph of President Obama conversing with some of his staff in the Oval Office with his feet up on his desk. That's about the only factual element to this item, as the accompanying text is mostly contrived, subjective invective intended to stir up partisan outrage:
 

  • In over half of the cultures of the world, it is recognized not only as disrespectful, but as an extreme insult to show the bottom of your shoes.

  • It is true that in some parts of the world showing the bottom of one's shoes (even accidentally) is considered rude, but it isn't true of American culture, nor do the areas where it does hold true (primarily the Middle East, Korea, Thailand, some parts of Africa) comprise anything close to "over half of the cultures of the world."
     

  • While this posture is disrespectful in any culture, it is absolutely never done in any executive setting.

  • "Absolutely never done"? It's not the norm, perhaps, but it's not "never done." Take, for example, this anecdote from a book about one of American's most prominent business executives, Apple co-founder and former CEO Steve Jobs:
    Bill Curley, a middle-aged Apple marketing manager, remembers this incident from his very first week on the job at Apple. "I was at a meeting with [Apple CEO Steve] Jobs and several other managers, and he is in shorts, running shoes, and no socks. He's disagreeing with a guy, so he kicks off his shoes and puts his bare feet on the table. He framed the guy's face with his feet."
    An executive's kicking his feet up on a desk or table is an action that can be regarded quite differently in varying contexts: Doing so in the middle of a staff meeting might be regarded as demonstrating rudeness, arrogance, or disrespect; on the other hand, doing so at the end of a long, hard workday while engaging in friendly chit-chat with a few subordinates might be perceived as showing oneself to be a warm, folksy, regular ol' guy.
     

  • He thinks of himself as a king -- and not as a servant of the people, humbly occupying our White House for his term in office. We should inundate the White House with emails demanding that he stop desecrating his office and keep his feet off of our furniture.

  • If a U.S. President's putting his feet up on the Oval Office desk is an indication that "he thinks of himself as a king" and should be "inundated" with mail "demanding he stop desecrating his office," then we seem to have missed the boat on that issue — identical actions by President Obama's predecessors in the White House provoked no such outrage, as demonstrated by the following unremarked-upon photographs of Presidents George W. Bush and Gerald Ford:




    Last updated:   11 February 2010

    Urban Legends Reference Pages © 1995-2014 by snopes.com.
    This material may not be reproduced without permission.
    snopes and the snopes.com logo are registered service marks of snopes.com.