s n o p e s . c o m   Military: Shouldering the Burden  
  Does a photograph show a U.S. serviceman wearing a 'DOING THE WORK OF' patch?
  snopes.com > Photo Gallery > Military > Shouldering the Burden
 

  Search snopes.com:    
  Contact Us

  Daily Snopes

  Top Searches

  Recent Additions

  Randomizer

  Message Board

  Donate

  FAQ

  Mailing Lists

  Glossary
  E-mail this page   Printer-friendly version

Shouldering the Burden

Claim:   Photograph shows a U.S. serviceman wearing a "DOING THE WORK OF" patch.

Status:   False.

Example:   [Collected on the Internet, 2004]


READ THE BLACK PATCH UNDER THE US FLAG

This SHOULD be on the front cover of Time, Newsweek, etc.

But it won't.

Let's you and I "put it there" by forwarding this all around the world (so to speak)!

Doing the work of . . .

(Click to enlarge)


Origins:   The image shown above began circulating on the Internet in early 2004 and is a digitally manipulated creation rather than a genuine photograph — the original can be found on a NATO-related web site:

Doing the work of . . .

The appearance of the sergeant's sleeve has been altered in the Internet-circulated version to reflect the viewpoint that the U.S. military has shouldered a burden of global importance with little or no support from the countries (Russia, Germany, France) whose flags are pictured below the "DOING THE WORK OF" patch.

Nothing about the photograph indicates where the U.S. is doing the work of these other countries. Presumably it is meant to refer to the invasion and rebuilding of Iraq (although the serviceman pictured isn't wearing the familiar desert camouflage uniforms we're used to seeing in that part of the world), but it could technically refer to Afghanistan or South Korea or anywhere else in the world where U.S. forces are deployed.

The backward appearance of the U.S. flag on the serviceman's sleeve in this picture is not a mistake or anomaly. As the military newspaper Stars & Stripes explained, the flag patch worn on the right shoulder of a U.S. soldier's uniform is deliberately reversed:
Why do American soldiers wear the U.S. flag insignia "backwards" on the right shoulder of their utility uniforms, with the canton (the rectangle with the stars) on an observer's right?

It's a question that soldiers hear frequently as they travel through civilian airports, or talk to members of other services.

And it does look "wrong," because U.S. federal code calls for the canton to always be positioned to the left.

The soldiers aren't wrong, however, and neither are their tailors, Lt. Col. Stanley Heath, an Army spokesman, explained in a Friday telephone interview.

The Army actually has two authorized flag patches, one to be worn on the left shoulder, with the canton facing left, and another "reverse field" patch worn on the right, with the canton facing right.

The two different orientations are mandated because Army regulations call for the flag "to be worn so that to observers, it looks as if the flag is flying against a breeze," Heath said.

What does a stiff wind have to do with this custom?

In fact, the rule is a nod to the U.S. Army's early history, when wars were fought as a series of carefully choreographed battles — two armies meeting on a field, clashing head-on until one side emerged victorious.

In those battles, both mounted cavalry and infantry units would always designate one soldier as "standard bearer," to carry the Colors into the fight.

As the standard bearer charged, his rapid forward momentum would cause the flag to stream back.

And since the Stars and Stripes is mounted with the canton closest to the pole, that section would always be forward.

So if a soldier is charging into the battle, the flag would give the appearance of forward motion. For the right shoulder, the flag only appears "backward."

And that's why soldiers wear the flag patches on the right shoulder "backward." Because retreat in battle, as any soldier will tell you, is not the Army way.
Last updated:   24 April 2004
 
The URL for this page is http://www.snopes.com/photos/military/patch.asp

Urban Legends Reference Pages © 1995-2014
by Barbara and David P. Mikkelson
This material may not be reproduced without permission


  Sources Sources:
    Burgess, Lisa.   "Is the Flag 'Backwards' on Soldiers' Sleeves?"
      Stars & Stripes.   28 February 2004.