Fact Check

Nepalese Baby

Fauxtography: Photographs purportedly show a bizarre-looking baby born in Nepal.

Published April 6, 2006

Claim:

Claim:   Photographs show a bizarre-looking baby born in Nepal.


TRUE


Example:   [Collected via e-mail, 2006]


Tell me this story is a hoax ... this "baby" looks like plastic.





 

Origins:   The above-displayed photographs accompanied an article published on eKantipur.com, describing the birth of a bizarre-looking baby on 29 March 2006 in the city of Charikot in Nepal. According to that article:



The neck-less baby with its head almost totally sunk into the upper part of the body and with extraordinarily large eyeballs literally popping out of the eye-sockets, was born to Nir Bahadur Karki and Suntali Karki at the Gaurishnkar Hospital in Charikot.

The bizarre baby, however, died after half an hour of its birth, Suntali, the mother, informed. It was taken to the hospital after its death.

The news about such a baby being brought to the hospital spread like wildfire and there were hundreds gathered at the hospital to have a look. The police had to be deployed to control the crowd.

"We wouldn't have been able to save it, even if it had been brought here alive," said a nurse attending to the mother at the hospital, "This is an extremely abnormal case."

The "baby" weighed 2kg at birth and was born after the normal nine-month gestation period.


We cautiously listed this item as "TRUE" although news items from parts of the world such as Nepal are difficult to independently verify. Even though the appearance of the baby pictured here may strike many viewers as freakishly unreal (and indeed, the article was dismissed as a hoax by many readers because it was published a few days before April Fools' Day), the child's physical appearance is consistent with that observed in documented cases of anencephaly, a birth defect described as:



A condition in which the embryologic closure of the neural tube never completes, leaving the embryo to develop without the upper portion of its skull. These embryos sometimes continue to develop into the fetal stage and may even survive to be born alive, but with upper cranium and scalp missing and the brain open to the outer world.

The web site of the University of Utah Health Sciences Center displays several photographs of similar cases of gross anencephaly:

The original article did not explain why one photograph seemingly showed the dead child being paraded around town in a washbin, but the activity was possibly part of a funeral or other ritualistic ceremony.

Last updated:   12 March 2015


Sources:




    Manandhar, Rajendra.   "Bizarre Baby Born in Dolakha."

    eKantipur.com.   29 March 2006.


David Mikkelson founded the site now known as snopes.com back in 1994.

Article Tags