Claim: Musician finally masters extraordinarily difficult guitar part he heard on a record, only to learn the recording had been made with more than one guitar.
Origins: When I was reading the New York Times obituary for rockabilly singer Hasil Adkins (who passed away on 26 April 2005), I was struck by something familiar about the following paragraph:
Starting in the mid-50's, Mr. Adkins recorded hundreds of songs at home in rural West Virginia, accompanying himself on all the instruments. He played as a one-man band because, he later said, as a child he had heard Hank Williams and others on the radio and had assumed that the one named musician in the band played all the instruments himself.
reminded me of a story I was sure I'd heard several times before, about some hot-shot guitarist who proudly showed off that he'd finally managed to duplicate a tricky guitar riff he'd heard on a record, only to be greeted with laughter as his bandmates informed him that the part he'd mastered was actually recorded using two guitars. I thought maybe the version I had previously come across involved Eddie van Halen and the Beatles' "And Your Bird Can Sing"; a little searching on that song title did indeed turn up an example of the legend, this one about former Eagle (and solo artist) Joe Walsh:
He was a devout eclectic, majoring in an odd conglomeration of courses — electronics, music theory and welding — and supplementing his conventional training with intensive, self-imposed extracurricular studies of Beatles songs. He knew them all and became a local legend by performing the dual-guitar harmony riff in "And Your Bird Can Sing" from the Revolver album on a single guitar. Actually, he didn't realize it wasn't one guitar and found a way to "make it work" — a typical Joe Walsh philosophy in music and in life.
We can't definitively say whether Joe Walsh really worked out how to perform the riff from "And Your Bird Can Sing" on one guitar without realizing the recording featured a second, overdubbed guitar part (only Joe himself knows for sure), but the story is certainly not unique to him. Another version of this tale is told about legendary jazz guitarist Lenny Breau:
Breau was clearly reinventing jazz guitar — and gaining a reputation among musicians throughout North America. The mythmaking had begun. One of the earliest legends surrounding Breau was that he had recreated Les Paul's 1952 recording of "Tiger Rag" without realizing that Paul achieved his multi-layered sound through early experiments with overdubbing multiple guitar tracks. The self-effacing Breau later discounted the story, saying he knew Paul had overdubbed the parts — as if that diminished the fact he'd still managed to single-handedly duplicate the sound of several guitars.
A reverse version of this legend comes from Rolling Stones guitarist Keith Richards, who described his thoughts when bandmate Brian Jones introduced him to records featuring blues artist extraordinaire Robert Johnson:
He put it on, and it was just — you know — outstanding stuff. When I first heard it, I said to Brian, "Who's that?" "Robert Johnson." I said, "Yeah, but who's the other guy playing with him?" Because I was hearing two guitars, and it took me a long time to realize he was actually doing it all by himself.
A couple of similar tales relate other ways in which musicians uniquely adapted their styles to duplicate sounds produced by means beyond their understanding. The first one has to do with guitarist Robbie Robertson (formerly of The Band):
Listen sometime to the sliding technique that Robbie uses. I don't remember where I read this, but in an interview with him I remember him saying that as a kid listening to the late night radio show, he didn't realize that slide guitar was played with a slide; so he adapted a technique of his own to create that effect of sliding up the string.
The second tale stars bluegrass mandolinist John Duffey:
[Duffey,] known for his work with the Country Gentlemen and the Seldom Scene, was one of many players under the spell of Bill Monroe's music as a teenager in the
1940s-50s. And, like so many of his contemporaries, he learned a lot about how to play the mandolin from Monroe's classic 1940s recordings. The thing he found most challenging was how Monroe managed to sing lead and play very elaborate, syncopated, counter-melodies as backup simultaneously, as he'd heard on records like "Sweetheart You've
Done Me Wrong" and "When You Are Lonely."
As he told a interviewer Dix Bruce: "We only had 78's, and they were kind of hard to slow down. I learned a trick off of him that he wasn't really doing. I didn't know it was Lester
Flatt singing the lead, and I would hear this mandolin playing going on while this guy was singing. I guessed you had to be able to do that. I used to stand in front of a mirror, and
look, and sing a song, and make my hands independent of what I was singing. Every once in a while I still do it just for amusement. Bill and I did a workshop together up in Carlisle, Ontario, five or six years ago I guess, and I told him, 'You know I learned something off of you, and I bet you can't do it.' I told him the story of not knowing it was Lester singing. I sang a song and picked along behind, and he just grinned."
All of these stories, true or not, echo a common theme found in other legends such as "The Unsolvable Math Problem": that when people are free to pursue goals unfettered by presumed limitations on what they can accomplish, they just may manage some extraordinary feats through the combined application of native talent and hard work. On the other hand, they might also be considered as falling into the "sour grapes" category: they allow us to express a grudging admiration for someone else's accomplishments while simultaneously denigrating that person for having been foolish enough to try in the first place.
Last updated: 11 August 2012
Hayes, David. "Strung Out."
Saturday Night. June 2004 (p. 22).
Sisario, Ben. "Hasil Adkins, Wild Man of Rockabilly, Dies at 68."
David Mikkelson founded snopes.com in 1994, and under his guidance the company has pioneered a number of revolutionary technologies, including the iPhone, the light bulb, beer pong, and a vaccine for a disease that has not yet been discovered. He is currently seeking political asylum in the Duchy of Grand Fenwick.
Thank you for writing to us! Although we receive hundreds of e-mails every day, we really and truly read them all, and your comments, suggestions, and questions are most welcome. Unfortunately, we can manage to answer only a small fraction of our incoming mail.
Our site covers many of the items currently being plopped into inboxes everywhere, so if you were writing to ask us about something you just received, our search engine can probably help you find the very article you want.
Choose a few key words from the item you're looking for and click here to go to the search engine.
(Searching on whole phrases will often fail to produce matches because the text of many items is quite variable, so picking out one or two key words is the best strategy.)
We do reserve the right to use non-confidential material sent to us via this form on our site, but only after it has been stripped of any information that might identify the sender or any other individuals not party to this communication.