|
Claim: A dying baby is brought back from the brink by the sound of her brother's singing.
Example: [Collected on the Internet, 1999]
Variations: Some versions mention that the mother is "an active member of the Panther Creek United Methodist Church in Morristown, Tennessee" or that the ailing baby is later baptized there; others leave out those details. (There is no Panther Creek United Methodist Church in that area Origins: This tear-jerking tale began wet hankying its way around the Internet in May 1998. Though it's a touching story about the power of love, those in the know at
a little boy have sung a favorite song to his ailing little sister who subsequently recovered from an
unspecified illness? It's possible, of course, but at this point nothing exists to substantiate the event other than an overly-dramatic much-circulated account no one can verify which includes details that are apparently false. Could a real event have inspired the current story, and the smuggling in of the brother been inserted by the writer to heighten the drama of the tale? Also possible, but if that is the case, one has to wonder how much of the story is dramatic flourish added by the chronicler and how much is fact. We do know the child wasn't languishing at death's door and her medical records indicate no radical changes in her condition while she was in care.
Barbara "sunshine on my overloaded shoulders" Mikkelson Last updated: 10 March 2007 This material may not be reproduced without permission. snopes and the snopes.com logo are registered service marks of snopes.com. |
|







a little boy have sung a favorite song to his ailing little sister who subsequently recovered from an
unspecified illness? It's possible, of course, but at this point nothing exists to substantiate the event other than an overly-dramatic much-circulated account no one can verify which includes details that are apparently false. Could a real event have inspired the current story, and the smuggling in of the brother been inserted by the writer to heighten the drama of the tale? Also possible, but if that is the case, one has to wonder how much of the story is dramatic flourish added by the chronicler and how much is fact. We do know the child wasn't languishing at death's door and her medical records indicate no radical changes in her condition while she was in care.