Claim: You should avoid eating green potatoes because they are poisonous.
WHAT'S TRUE: Green potatoes contain a natural toxin called solanine.
WHAT'S FALSE: You are unlikely to ingest enough solanine from eating green potatoes to do you any serious harm.
Origin:The potato, the ultimate comfort food in Western society, has a disturbing secret. This trustworthy old friend so often invited to our tables can, at times, slip us a little bit of poison.
The potato — or, rather, green versions of
A glycoalkaloid poison found in species of the nightshade, solanine is a nerve toxin produced in the green part of the potato (the leaves, the stem, and any green spots on the skin). This bitter poisonous crystalline alkaloid is part of the plant's defenses against insects, disease, and predators. Potato leaves and stems are naturally high in glycoalkaloids, so ingestion of these parts of the plant should be avoided.
Solanine develops in potatoes when spuds are subjected to light or either very cold or very warm temperatures. The toxin interferes with the body's ability to use a particular chemical that facilitates the transmission of impulses between cells. Ingested in large enough amounts, it can cause vomiting, diarrhea, headaches, and even paralysis of the central nervous system.
However, unless you are deliberately seeking out green potatoes to eat, you are unlikely to ingest enough of the toxin to do harm. The potatoes we buy contain such a minute amount of the chemical that a healthy adult would have to eat about
Contemporary lore contains a well-traveled tale that expounds on a different danger a green potato might pose:
During the 1976 Soweto uprising, a bunch of township youths paint a potato green. As an armoured car rolls past them, with a soldier sitting in the turret, they lob the "grenade" into the car. All the soldiers inside scramble out, sans weapons, and the youths leap in and commandeer the vehicle. The story is, naturally, hushed up by the authorities.
As to whether the preceding is a true story, as noted South African folklorist Arthur Goldstuck said of it: "This story is uniquely 1970s South African. Or 1960s Saigon. Or 1940s France."
Last updated: 07 September 2016
Originally published: 23 November 2006
Beatty, Denise. "Green Spots Indicate Potato Has Been Damaged."
The Toronto Star. 19 November 1986 (p. E17).
Brunvand, Jan Harold. The Baby Train.
New York: W. W. Norton, 1993. ISBN 0-393-31208-9 (p. 127).
Kelly, Peter. "Stop on Green."
The Boston Globe. 4 December 2005 (Magazine, p. 59).
Kerrigan, Jack. "Alkaloid Turns Spud Green: Think What It Can Do to Us!"
[Cleveland] Plain Dealer. 23 December 2000 (p. H9).
Sass, Lorna. "Say Hello to the Simple Spudvegetarian View."
The Oregonian. 13 March 1990 (Food Day; p. 8).
The Big Book of Urban Legends.
New York: Paradox Press, 1994. ISBN 1-56389-165-4 (p. 187).