Example: [Collected on the Internet, 1995]
- Though the weiner is most often retrieved from the vagina, it's sometimes fished out of the girl's rectum.
- In one especially disgusting version, after failing to get the hot dog out by herself, the girl leaves it in there for weeks. A burning sensation in her nether regions encourages her to seek medical help, and when the bits of hot dog are pulled out, they're discovered to be crawling with maggots. This expression of the hot dog legend mirrors another urban legend about tuna put to similar use.
- The girl's masturbatory experiments usually take place when she's alone, not at a party. She's often characterized as stuck up and haughty, someone who routinely turns down dates.
- An unusual variation has the hot dog being returned to the refrigerator after doing its service and the girl's brother later scarfing it down, unaware of its history.
- A related legend stars not a hotdog but a Coke bottle. In that tale, the girl requires medical attention to break the seal the suction has caused.
Underlying the tale is the standard "embarrassing sexual doings brought to light" theme: we find out the girl has been masturbating through the plot device of her requiring medical assistance to dislodge the item she'd been pleasuring herself with. A similar urban legend about a girl who uses a bottle rather than a hotdog relies on the same plot point. In both tales, the hospital trip is a necessary element because without it no one would know what these sexually curious gals had been up to. Both are 'perils of masturbation' stories and when told among girls impart the moral "This could happen to you." Similarly, the "Promiscuous Cheerleader" legend calls upon the meme of kinky sexual behavior revealed through the need for medical intervention. Doctor/patient confidentiality does not appear to factor into many urban legends.
Obviously, the hot dog in this particular legend is there because of its somewhat resemblance to a penis.
This legend probably originated as a salacious tale from a more chauvinistic era, one intended to put a socially-successful, overly-snobby or unattainable girl in her place. By portraying her as overcome by desire, she's taken off her pedestal and made human; by having the handling of her physical urges lead to an embarrassment, she's brought down to a level where boys who'd lusted after her can now view themselves as somewhat her superior and thus need no longer feel inadequate in her presence.
In a larger sense, such legends work to reassure adolescent boys that all girls are sex objects and there isn't one of them they can't be having wild fantasies about. When one can believe that even the highest of the high have gotten down with a hot dog, graphic day dreams about any girl no longer seem out of place. Telling — and believing — such tales is a way of combating fear of rejection by building up bravado. The frightening, all-powerful girl is made an object of derision, thus working to dispel a boy's fear of asking her (or any other girl) out.
Rumors like this can do their target a lot of damage. In 1993 the first suit in the nation seeking damages from a school or school official for peer harassment was filed against the Petaluma City School District. According to the suit, a seventh-grader was taunted daily by dozens of students after one boy spread the rumor she had masturbated with a hot dog. Failing to get any help through the system, her family had to uproot and leave town. Though the suit against the school counselor failed, in 1996 the school system settled with the girl for $250,000 without admitting any wrongdoing.
Barbara "ball park frank" Mikkelson
Last updated: 24 June 2011
Anderson, Nick. "Educators Get a Lesson in Sexual Harrassment." Los Angeles Times. 14 December 1997 (p. A1). Easton, Nina. "The Law of the School Yard." Los Angeles Times. 2 October 1994 (Magazine; p. 16). Holding, Reynolds. "Court Rules Against Ex-Petaluma Student in Peer Harrassment Case." The San Francisco Chronicle. 13 May 1996 (p. A1). Lehrman, Sally. "Schools Learn the Hard Way; Harrassment Not Child's Play." The San Francisco Examiner. 3 October 1996 (p. A1).